The facts
Can any government keep up the payments?
Since 1970, New Zealand has produced surpluses big enough to support this scheme only twice – both during the 1990s. And National took a lot of hits at the time for being "mean" on spending in order to deliver those surpluses.
A straitjacket for future governments
There won't be anything like enough money left over to boost education, or pump up our universities and our research capacity, or other policies that we need to get the economy up and running. It also means there will be no room for tax incentives or lower taxes. For instance, it would be almost impossible to drop the company tax rate to match Australia.
What Cullen told Cabinet
"In making the contribution to retirement income policy more certain, pre-funding would shift fiscal risks onto other spending policies. This would mean that other policies would bear both a greater proportion of the risk of variability in tax revenue and fiscal demands due to economic shocks, and the residual risk arising from the variability in investment returns on the fund …
"While affordable in the longer term, when the Budget Policy Statement was prepared in March we considered that this initial requirement [of $2 billion a year] could potentially be too much to impose all at once without compromising other short-term fiscal objectives for debt and spending."
Which, in plain English, means that when you’re committing $2 billion a year to the fund, something else has to give.
Where to invest the fund?
Already the Alliance is talking about a much higher level of new Zealand investment. The return for taxpayers would not be nearly so attractive.
And the Greens want to insist on social, environmental and ethical investing priorities. Where would that leave the returns for taxpayers?
This is the first issue of National's new superannuation newsletter The Fundamentals.« ACT gives its views on the Big Cullen Fund | AMP & Good Returns launch superannuation website » |
Special Offers
© Copyright 1997-2024 Tarawera Publishing Ltd. All Rights Reserved