Harvard Business Review Slams Cullen Super Fund

The prestigious Harvard Business Review was quite right in slamming the Cullen Super Fund for its sloppy accountability says ACT Finance Spokesman Rodney Hide.

Thursday, December 5th 2002, 11:44AM

The prestigious Harvard Business Review was quite right in slamming the Cullen Super Fund for its sloppy accountability, ACT Finance Spokesman Rodney Hide says.

The article appears in the November Harvard Business Review pp. 52-62 and is titled "Arm yourself for the Coming Battle Over Social Security". The article is by Robert Pozen who is the John Olin Visiting Professor at Harvard Law School, a member of President Bush's Commission to Strengthen Social Security.

Pozen writes (p.62):

More systematically, the World Bank has done a comparative analysis of countries investing pension assets directly through a government agency versus countries that allow citizens to invest through personal accounts. Its analysis, published in 2001, shows that returns from government investing have been significantly lower than returns from personal investing. The culprit is politics.

New Zealand, for example, recently established an independent board to invest its Social Security assets in a manner consistent with "maximising return without undue risk to the Fund as a whole". However, because of legislative pressures, the board was simultaneously directed to invest these assets according to another standard that no one can define: "avoiding prejudice to New Zealand's reputation as a responsible member of the world community".

This nebulous second standard will make it impossible to hold the board accountable for inferior financial returns; it can always attribute its underperformance to protecting New Zealand's reputation.

"Mr Pozen is quite right - as was pointed out to Mr Cullen at the time. New Zealanders should be most concerned at the sloppy accountability inherent in the management of the Super Fund. They would do far better if Michael Cullen simply trusted New Zealanders with their own money," Hide says.

« Global gamble costs super fund $5000 per memberAMP & Good Returns launch superannuation website »

Special Offers

Commenting is closed


© Copyright 1997-2020 Tarawera Publishing Ltd. All Rights Reserved