Pricing chaos in home loan market

There is “chaos” in pricing of home loans, according to one bank chief executive and borrowers have all the power.

Wednesday, April 16th 2014, 12:01PM 6 Comments

The Co-operative Bank chief executive Bruce McLachlan says there is significant discounting happening amongst lenders.

“Rate cards are quite high in my view,” he says.

Borrowers need to be asking for the best possible deal when they take out a loan or refinance an exiting one.

“The poor old customers who don’t challenge are missing out,” he says.

ANZ economists agree competition has stepped up in the past few weeks.

“All power to the borrowers!”

“Competition is more aggressive in the Auckland and Christchurch area; precisely those regions that are the house price hot-spots,” they say in the latest Market Focus report.

One of the reasons is that lenders have got their minds around the Reserve Bank’s lending restrictions and have realised there is room to increase their activity in this area.

McLachlan says just under seven per cent of The Co-operative Bank’s lending is in the low equity space and he would like it to be around 8%.

ANZ says: “The initial knee-jerk reaction post the implementation of the 10% limit on high LVR lending partly reflected uncertainty surrounding how the swathe of pre-approved loans would roll off. Six months on and financial intermediaries have managed that pipeline so high LVR lending can tick back up closer to the 10% threshold.”

The other reason is that a sizable chunk of fixed rate mortgages rolling off at present which presents an opportunity to gain market share.

McLachlan is critical of the discounting happening in the market and says The Co-operative Bank does minimal discounting and tries to be “transparent” with its pricing.

How they compare
The following graph illustrates the differences in pricing at the moment. For practical reasons we have selected a sample of lenders rather than trying to graph all of them.

« Welcome Home Loans to expandEconomists: Expect another increase »

Special Offers

Comments from our readers

On 16 April 2014 at 4:12 pm Amused said:
Leaving aside what the ANZ economists are saying about “competition” ANZ remains as of today the only main bank to have two tier interest rates advertised for new home loan customers borrowing above 80%. No other main bank lender in New Zealand is making its customers pay more automatically for new home loans approved with less than 20% equity. Why is ANZ then still charging its customers more?
On 17 April 2014 at 8:26 am Kymmy said:
Why haven't you included Kiwibank in your comparison...?
I would have thought you'd be more supportive since they are consistently competitive.
On 17 April 2014 at 9:22 am The Editor said:
As noted in the article we selected a number of lenders to show the differences. Adding all banks to the graph would make it impossible to read.
The Co-operative Bank was selected as the article included comments from its CEO and SBS was the second small bank as it consistently has the lowest pricing. Interestingly neither of the small banks get involved in all the giveaways.
On 17 April 2014 at 10:42 am Amused said:
Kiwibank consistently competitive? Really? Care to look back Kymmy at how much more Kiwibank and its insurer QBE used to charge borrowers on low equity premiums above 80%? Kiwibank were thousands of dollars more expensive compared than the other banks.

Kiwibank hid behind their six year home loan guarantee which was clearly a load of baloney on these types of low equity mortgages.

Anyone with a calculator could have figured that out! Unfortunately a lot of people fell for Kiwibank’s marketing spin and paid a significantly higher cost by electing to have their mortgage with them.

No doubt some of these borrowers are sadly still paying off the higher low equity premium charged by Kiwibank originally to approve their loan before they even begin to make inroads now on the principal amount they borrowed.
On 17 April 2014 at 3:48 pm Richard said:
Why has New Zealand consistently have the highest interest rates in the western world? Why does areas outside of Auckland and Christchurch have to suffer increases in interest rates when their economies are still really struggling?
On 22 April 2014 at 4:58 pm Ron Topping said:
You probably answered the question yourself Richard.
They are a higher risk!

Sign In to add your comment

www.GoodReturns.co.nz

© Copyright 1997-2024 Tarawera Publishing Ltd. All Rights Reserved