Capital gains tax back on the menu?

Tax reform is one of those phrases which we are all going to hear a lot about in coming months and one suggestion already being aired is a capital gains tax on property.

Property investor lobby groups made it clear before last year’s election that, vote for Labour and you vote for a capital gains tax on property.

Vote for National and you’re safe, they said.

The argument went that Labour was keen on a CGT and so too were its likely support partners, the Greens and the Maori Party.

Well hello; investors got their National-led government and its Finance Minister Bill English seems interested in the idea of a CGT on property, or some form of land tax. Yes, he has acknowledged that it may be hard to get through the National party caucus, but I am sure if he wants to he will succeed.

While New Zealand may be out of line on this one with many of its peer countries, I am happy for that to be the case as there is little evidence a CGT works in keeping house prices down.

The other side of the argument which is difficult to fathom is that many argue Kiwis shouldn’t invest in residential property. Well if this group of more than a quarter of a million people aren’t prepared to own, finance and manage houses, who is going to?

Property investment is a legitimate form of investment. Investors are landlords and providing a service industry – accommodation.

Do we really want house prices to fall 30%? That would see a huge loss of wealth to the community and no doubt put some major strains on the economy.

While I don’t think the people making these claims have much credibility with their forecasting, the fact that they get so much air time is scary.

Leave these things like CGT on property alone. Previously the playing field was tilted in favour of property investors, however changes in recent years, such as KiwiSaver and the PIE tax regime have evened up the score.

It will take time for people to shift and change their investment patterns, but it will happen – slowly.

Instead of a CGT on property, more effort should be made in strengthening and deepening the capital markets so there are other investment opportunities.