KiwiSaver
Cullen's Super Policy Losing $83,000 a Week!
Monday 21st of January 2002
- Michael
Cullen is borrowing every dollar that he has so far set aside
for the fund. Such a super scheme in the private sector would
see Michael Cullen sent straight to jail yet another argument
in favour of privatisation.
- The accounts report: As at 30 November 2001 the amounts held by the New Zealand Debt Management Office totalled $256 million (including interest accrued at the official cash rate) (p.4).
- The accounts also report the Governments financing requirement over the five-month period to be $549 million (p.7).
- So Michael Cullen has set aside $256 million for future super, while borrowing an extra $549 million. Brilliant! His strategy is to increase the mortgage on the house to invest in the stock market. Precisely what every investment adviser in the country warns not to do, for obvious reasons.
- But whats worse is that Michael Cullens super fund is already losing money. He has yet to invest it. He has it stuffed in a bureaucratic sock earning just 4.75 percent (the Official Cash Rate). But hes had to borrow the $549 million at 6.44 percent (the ten year bond rate). The difference is 1.69 percent and this is what Michael Cullen is already losing taxpayers on his fund. The cost just this week of Michael Cullens super fund is $83,200.
- Only Michael Cullen would ever have the gall to borrow at 6.44 percent and invest at 4.75 and call that a pension fund. The rest of us would quite rightly call it a fraud, Rodney Hide concluded.
Want to read the full article?
Click the button below to subscribe and will have free unlimited access for a limited time to full article and all other articles on the site.
You will also be able to comment on articles on Good Returns.
Latest News
3 min read
Latest Comments
Income protection faces a rethink as traditional jobs disappear
The question I have is what Insurance coimpanies are doing at UW time in a case such as the 39yr old haridresser that is used as an example here.
Are they still only insuring the primary occupation? And are they still excluding any other occupations?
3 days ago Just an opinion
Simplicity fund reclassification ‘may have boosted returns’
Morningstar's classifications are certainly questionable at times. Another great example is Boosters Geared Growth fund's sitting in 'Miscellaneous' as opposed to 'Aggressive'. It is no secret another manager pushed hard to make it happen. I would not be surprised if it is the same manager not wanting to be named in the article.
Several other funds have changed over time in their target asset allocations and resultant classification, it is not just Simplicity. Blindly looking at Morningstars rankings (or anyone else's for that matter) misses key information about funds and managers - target asset allocation is only a part of the story. Understanding this is where good advisers set themselves apart.
4 days ago AThought
Simplicity fund reclassification ‘may have boosted returns’
The Morningstar classification rules have always been problematic. Their split kicks you from Balanced - Growth at just 60% in Equities verus MJW's 69% and Sorted/FMA's 63%. Likewise if you exceed 80% in Equities you get re-classified from Growth - Aggressive versus MJW's 85% and Sorted/FMA's 90% splits respectively. In some parts of the world Aggresive is classed as 95% - 100% Equities.
5 days ago Peter Urbani
Advisers embrace Westpac after trail commissions removed
@ The Laird - I wasn't suggesting the increase in upfront from Westpac caused the small uplift in adviser-generated loans.
You rightly point out this hypothesis is not supported by the evidence. Nor is the hypothesis that an uplift in adviser-generated loans following the removal of trail commissions suggests that advisers are not predominantly driven by commission considerations.
The UK report is flawed, for the same reason the 2016 FMA work on churn is flawed. Neither regulator is looking in the right place/at the right data, if they're looking to find evidence of "churn".
To be clear: I am not suggesting there is a "churn" problem. Only that the lapse-rate spike following the end of the clawback period is not the place to look.
5 days ago Paul Flood
Advisers embrace Westpac after trail commissions removed
@Paul - maybe so, but that's a hypothetical claim for which there is no evidence.
The reality is that here, and from the recent UK report on risk commissions, there appears to be no empirical evidence that remuneration is the dominant influence in product recommendations from intermediaries.
Whether we ever move to a fee charging environment in the mortgage advice space seems unlikely.
The UK report suggested that the research identified no significant client harm based on adviser commissions.
6 days ago The Laird