KPMG warns of Westpoint type collapse in NZ
High commissions for advisers and brokers to place investments with high-risk finance companies run the risk of a West Point-style scandal in New Zealand, says KPMG.
Wednesday, May 3rd 2006, 6:59AM
by Rob Hosking
The extent of those risks is likely to be exposed if the economic slowdown lasts for a significant period.
“From my perspective I don’t have a problem with brokers or advisers getting a commission to source funds,” says KPMG deputy chairman Godfrey Boyce.
“It’s when the commission is too large it causes problems. Anything above 1.5-2% is cause for concern.” Something like the West Point scandal in Australia, where advisers and brokers steered a considerable amount of client money in return for high commissions, is “at the extreme end” but it could happen, he says.
“If someone is paying that sort of commission what does that say about their own ability to generate funds?”
KPMG chairman Andrew Dinsdale advocates for much tighter rules for finance companies, including minimum capital ratios at the same level as for banks; comparable ratings by credit ratings agencies, eg by standard and Poors or Moodys; more consistency and transparency between trustee companies, and much greater oversight of the sector by the Securities Commission.
“The key reason to subject non-bank players to a similar level of scrutiny [as banks] are the amount of depositors’ money involved, the resultant systemic risk, and the fact that customers are being promised ‘secured debentures’,” says Dinsdale.
Rob Hosking is a Wellington-based freelance writer specialising in political, economic and IT related issues.
| « Unions to get into KiwiSaver | Sovereign takes regulation bull by the horns » |
Special Offers
Commenting is closed
|
|
Printable version |
|
Email to a friend |
