Morningstar gives unwanted Xmas presents
Morningstar gives two managers Christmas presents they can't return.
Sunday, January 7th 2001, 11:34PM
On the Friday before Christmas Morningstar downgraded AMP from a five star manager to a four star one. Likewise it dropped BT Funds Management Australia from a four star rating to a three.
The reasons for the two downgrades were similar.
Morningstar maintains that a growing number of funds managed by each company have suffered significant drops in both performance and quality.
In AMP's case Morningstar says: "The downgrade has been driven by a fall in the Morningstar Star Ratings of many of AMP’s funds."
"The percentage of AMP funds with five star Morningstar Star Ratings has fallen sharply (down from 34 percent at 30 June 2000 to 12 percent at 30 November 2000), while the percentage of one star funds has more than doubled, from eight to 18 percent over the same period."
Morningstar, which has just completed a two yearly review of AMP, says that the company has been downgraded in a number of areas, including: corporate strength, administration and distribution, and investment management.
It says the company is below average in all these areas.
Likewise it says that the performance of AMP's funds have been falling in the past six months.
It says, "63% of AMP’s funds had achieved consistently average or better performance over the short-, medium- and long-term from both a risk and return perspective compared to peers at 30 June 2000. However, this trended downwards to 59 percent by 30 November 2000."
"The lower Ql (qualitative) Ratings and declining Qt (quantitative) Ratings led to lower Morningstar Star Ratings for many of AMP’s funds. Ultimately, this meant that at 30 November 2000 AMP fell below the benchmark required to maintain a five star Morningstar Star Rating, and therefore achieved four stars, denoting a ‘very good’ quality fund manager in Morningstar’s opinion."
Good Returnswill provide more detail on these downgrades and reaction from the managers later this week.
You can read Philip's blog here: http://www.goodreturns.co.nz/blog/
|« Welcome to 2001||Get your tax questions answered online »|
Commenting is closed
|Printable version||Email to a friend|