|        About Good Returns  |  Advertise  |  Contact Us  |  Terms & Conditions  |  RSS Feeds

NZ's Financial Adviser News Centre

GR Logo
Last Article Uploaded: Friday, August 14th, 7:08PM


Latest Headlines

Nagging and the definition of ‘financial advice’

Once upon a time we had this corporate guru come and talk to us about teams and communications.

Monday, August 28th 2017, 9:13AM 1 Comment

by Russell Hutchinson

They talked about how we get failures in communication a lot when we use the same words, but mean different things. The example given was a couple: one thought he was being nagged, the other thought she didn’t nag him. Separately, they were asked to write down a practical definition of nagging. She wrote down ‘asked a dozen times’. He wrote down ‘asked more than once’.

The same thing is going on right now in the arguments over financial advice law – the magic words ‘financial advice’ mean different things to different people.

Brent Sheather writes about the people in ‘polo shirts’ who can only sell one product for one company; they aren’t giving advice as he knows it. The law allows that to be called financial advice, because an opinion is given recommending a product considering the person’s circumstances. MBIE and our regulators see advice as a procedural thing, rather than a question of product choice. To be fair, they point to consumer surveys which shows that when consumers walk into a bank, they expect to be sold a bank product. On the other hand, they expect that when they talk to a financial adviser, they get some financial advice – which is a very big assumption, given that a lot of those ‘advisers’ only make ‘no advice sales’ – and that’s true in banks, but also true a lot outside of banks, too.

Some people don’t think that you can "give financial advice" unless you offer several products. The number at which you cease to be a ‘sales person’ and become and ‘adviser’ is something of a mystery. Most people agree that it is greater than one company, and at the other end of the spectrum, most courts agree that you do not have to consider every product everywhere in the world. Nor do you have to consider every other possible use for the money. You are allowed to limit the universe in some ways, provided you do it clearly.  How many is enough? The old NZ Mortgage Brokers Association (now part of the PAA) used to require members to have agencies with at least six providers of lending to qualify. The Trowbridge report in Australia recommended that bank-owned advice channels be required to deal with at least half the insurers in the market (which would have been about ten) – but that recommendation was never taken up.

I like to think that some level of product choice is a good thing to have when seeking advice; whether the magic number is three, six, or ten, I’m not sure.  But then there are those people who think that if you have anything to do with product, you’re conflicted. You must be fee only, and do no implementation. That’s like my accountants – they handle no money, apart from when I pay their bill. They just advise.

But whatever your definition of advice is, I’m willing to bet that your definition differs a bit from the one in the law. Fortunately, you are free to define what you think constitutes ‘good financial advice’ and tell that story to as many people as you can. Plus, you don’t have to wait till the Bill is passed.

Tags: banks Brent Sheather financial advisers MoBIE PAA regulation Russell Hutchinson

« Goal-based insurance planningInsurance cover and suicide rates »

Special Offers

Comments from our readers

On 29 August 2017 at 6:36 am Referee said:
Brilliant Russell - life can be so simple when you break it down!

Sign In to add your comment



Printable version  


Email to a friend
Insurance Briefs

Insurer nib backs Ronald McDonald House with $20k investment
Health insurer nib New Zealand and its nib foundation have lent support to Ronald McDonald House Charities.

Less stressed during lockdown
New Zealander’s health and wellbeing had surprising benefits from the Covid-19 lockdown.

Southern Cross supports new safe haven for at-risk pets
Southern Cross Pet Insurance has teamed up with Pet Refuge to provide temporary shelter for animals affected by family violence.

nib Foundation supports Lifeline to the tune of $150,000
To support the growing mental health needs of Kiwis emerging from the Covid-19 pandemic, Lifeline Aotearoa has increased its service capacity thanks to a $150,000 grant from nib foundation, the charitable arm of nib New Zealand (nib).

News Bites
Latest Comments
  • a2: could the milk be starting to turn?
    “Great Fundemental look.I guess in the ASX50 . as long as Aussies still love buying the Dip..its no worries Graeme Adams...”
    18 hours ago by Graeme33
  • It starts with governance
    “Hi David and thanks for your words also. I did read the FMA stuff before the post and also in my first response mention...”
    20 hours ago by gavin austin adviser business compliance
  • AMP reports profit drop amid 'solid' result
    “Sadly, AMP is becoming less and less relevant. Apart from this tiny blip of positive cash inflow, they've been bleeding clients...”
    20 hours ago by Contrarian
  • It starts with governance
    “Good words Gavin - might also mention the FMA publication -”
    21 hours ago by dcwhyte
  • It starts with governance
    “adviser1 - go talk to Partners Life. they have a great tool to help with this sort of stuff. ...”
    22 hours ago by Tash
Subscribe Now

Mortgage Rates Newsletter

Daily Weekly

Previous News


Most Commented On
About Us  |  Advertise  |  Contact Us  |  Terms & Conditions  |  Privacy Policy  |  RSS Feeds  |  Letters  |  Archive  |  Toolbox
Site by Web Developer and