About Good Returns  |  Advertise  |  Contact Us  |  Terms & Conditions  |  RSS Feeds Other Sites:   tmmonline.nz  |   landlords.co.nz
Last Article Uploaded: Thursday, July 18th, 7:09PM
Latest Headlines

'Mediators always side with clients'

A case in which an insurance broker was criticised for not conducting a full review of a client’s policy at renewal is being held up as a warning to other advisers.

Thursday, November 8th 2018, 6:00AM 2 Comments

The issue arose when Newpark General took over the fire and general clients of another adviser.

A year before that transfer, the previous adviser had reviewed the clients’ cover and downgraded it to a policy that excluded their swimming pool.

Newpark General then renewed the policy on the same terms, with a notice to the client including a summary of their cover and policy wordings, and a schedule reflecting benefits, insured risks and values.

This was sent with the policy wording and an invoice and note asking the client to advise Newpark if they wanted to change anything.

The client then suffered earthquake damage and claimed for a swimming pool repair.

The insurer declined the claim.

“I think they either simply forgot it wasn’t insured, or the original adviser never told them the cover was removed,” said adviser Herman Roodt.

“They then took us to the DRS FSCL for mediation which was also attended by the original adviser and his PI insurer’s representative. This adviser’s PI insurer immediately attacked me saying we should have done a full review of covers, which I rejected as no advice was given, and with domestic F&G the norm is not to review domestic cover personally with clients. It is just not viable to do personal reviews with all domestic clients. These renewals are all done via electronic/paper correspondence."

He said, after he left the meeting, the original adviser accepted his mistake and offered to pay 50 per cent of the $34,000 claim.

The client has now gone to the Disputes Tribunal and Roodt said he would be attending a telephone conciliation meeting next month for the remaining $15,000.

He said advisers often felt that mediators acted with bias towards a client – and a similar thing could happen to those dealing in life policies.

“The mediator always believes the bid bag wolf insurance adviser (or it’s company) has deep pockets and unlimited PI insurance and the poor client who never did anything wrong should be compensated irrespective of whether it’s right or not."

Tags: complaints

« Health funds stats 'hark back 20 years'Insurers grapple with increasing genetic testing »

Special Offers

Comments from our readers

On 8 November 2018 at 9:37 am Mr Slater said:
Herman I don't know the specifics of your case but I do have to strongly disagree with your comments that mediators side with clients.

I have been a mediator for over 20 years and I can say this is not my practice or the practice of the mediators that I know.

Mediation should be about exploring the issues and looking for options to resolve the dispute that both parties can live with, not pushing the person with money to pay compensation.

If that's what you experienced then it sounds to me you didn't have a good mediation. I hope your next experience is better.
On 9 November 2018 at 10:11 am Referee said:
I fully agree with Trevor's comments from first hand experience. Early action with facilitation and/or mediation is certainly the best form of resolution.

Sign In to add your comment



Printable version  


Email to a friend
Insurance Briefs

Future actuary rewarded

nib expands First Choice network
nib has announced an expansion of its First Choice network, which the health insurer says has delivered more than $1 million in claims savings in the first year of operation.

Fidelity Life team up for award
Fidelity Life chief technology Officer Dan Wilkinson and his team have been named as a finalist in the Best ICT Team Culture category at the 2019 New Zealand CIO Awards.

Cigna to support kids' mental health
Cigna New Zealand and Life Education have partnered to develop Small Changes Whānau Challenge, a new take-home resource that will support classroom learning about kids’ mental health and wellbeing.

News Bites
Latest Comments
  • Pathfinder-backed KiwiSaver to target gender diversity
    “This is a great initiative by Pathfinder - congratulations on taking a risk, and standing up for something that you believe...”
    16 hours ago by Pragmatic
  • Call to ensure efficient advice licensing
    “@all Put your cheque books away - no need to pay the lawyers to do the research to provide an opinion...... In my old...”
    1 day ago by Murray Weatherston
  • Call to ensure efficient advice licensing
    “Further reading - Kinsington Swan in February 2018 https://www.kensingtonswan.com/news-updates-and-events/financial-advice-reforms-insights-series-14-penalties-enforcement-complaints-and-disciplinary-matters/...”
    2 days ago by all hat, no cattle
  • Call to ensure efficient advice licensing
    “MPT and Murray this might help https://www.fma.govt.nz/assets/Fact-sheets/Who-will-need-a-licence-to-provide-financial-advice...”
    2 days ago by all hat, no cattle
  • Call to ensure efficient advice licensing
    “Thanks Murray, it seems we are on the same page. Be great if the regulators could confirm or not. AHNC, I agree I dont...”
    2 days ago by MPT Heretic
Subscribe Now

Cover Notes - Specific news aimed at risk advisers

Previous News


Most Commented On
About Us  |  Advertise  |  Contact Us  |  Terms & Conditions  |  Privacy Policy  |  RSS Feeds  |  Letters  |  Archive  |  Toolbox
Site by Web Developer and eyelovedesign.com