|        About Good Returns  |  Advertise  |  Contact Us  |  Terms & Conditions  |  RSS Feeds

NZ's Financial Adviser News Centre

GR Logo
Last Article Uploaded: Friday, July 23rd, 7:18PM


Latest Headlines

Insurers call for replacement business rules in code

Insurance firms and other commentators asked for more rules around replacement business and the ongoing servicing of clients to be included in the industry’s new code of conduct.

Monday, April 15th 2019, 6:00AM

Naomi Ballantyne

Submissions that were made during the code working group’s consultation period have been released ahead of the approval of the new code, which will apply to all advisers.

Naomi Ballantyne’s submission on behalf of Partners Life said there were significant risks in consumers replacing a financial product – such as insurance – with another.

“In these situations, a provider of financial advice should not be permitted to recommend a replacement financial advice product to a retail client unless the provider of financial advice compares the risks and benefits of the existing financial product to those of the new financial advice product, relative to the client’s personal circumstances.”

She said the only exception should be if the client proactively refused advice.

“Unless product documentation is compared by an expert, there is a risk that retail clients will not make fully informed decisions and be in a worse position with a substitute product,” she said.

“There is a significant risk of this occurring in cases of life and health insurance. For example, replacing one trauma policy for another, may mean the complete loss of cover if the client suffers a trauma condition not covered by the new policy. This is particularly relevant for cancer, where definitions of what qualifies for a claim benefit differs dramatically between policies. These differences can only be determined by analysis and comparison.”

Ballantyne said lost benefits were not the only risk – pre-existing conditions were catching clients out.

“As an example, a client has a medical policy which does not exclude ‘genetic pre-disposition’. She is recommended a new medical policy which includes such an exclusion. Because the policies are not compared, she and the adviser are unaware of the difference in cover. A few years later she is diagnosed with breast cancer and BRACA gene mutation which pre-disposes her to breast cancer. Her surgery and treatment are not covered under the new policy. It would have been covered under the previous policy.”

She said the code should also address products being replaced without advice.

David Whyte, chairman of Lifetime, said replacement business had to be managed carefully, with written documentation on the merits being provided to the client, the provider they were moving from and the one they were moving to.

AIA said there was also a gap in the standards relating to the ongoing support and servicing of clients, which the Financial Services Council said was a view shared by several of its members.

“For long-term products such as investment products and life insurance, we consider that there should be a positive obligation to provide ongoing periodic servicing and support to clients, unless the client makes an informed decision to the contrary,” AIA said.

“This should also address appropriate remuneration (trail commissions) where the clients may not be receiving adequate levels of service to warrant payment of on-going service commissions. This was a key issue identified in the Australian Royal Commission.”

But Russell Hutchinson, of Chatswood Consulting, said it could be difficult to implement.

“I am not in favour of the code requiring certain types of service, charge, or economic activity.

That was rejected by MBIE in drafting the law and if you like innovation, flexibility, and freedom, then you probably think that was a good idea. I am also concerned as to how we would define the service, at what thresh-hold level of renewal commission we might require it, and whether we might bind an adviser to a situation where they were required by the code to provide a service that was uneconomic, in the case of very small renewal commissions.

But the problem is real, as illustrated from Australia, is when a financial adviser receives a payment for no service given. Plainly, this is wrong.”

He said an alternative solution was for code standard one to include commentary making it clear that it was never fair to receive a fee or commission when no service was provided and no attempt made to do so.

Tags: AIA Churn Partners Life Russell Hutchinson

« Cigna plans OnePath changesnib finds ways to target advisers, post Fidelity deal »

Special Offers

Comments from our readers

No comments yet

Sign In to add your comment



Printable version  


Email to a friend
Insurance Briefs

Flood claims cost almost $45 million
Insurance customers in the Canterbury region lodged 3,538 claims costing over $43.8 million in losses following the May 29 - June 1 floods according to provisional figures released by the Insurance Council of New Zealand (ICNZ).

AIA Vitality partners with Countdown and New Balance
AIA NZ has announced further enhancements to AIA Vitality in the lead up to the second anniversary of its flagship health and wellbeing programme in New Zealand.

ICNZ launches te reo Maori title
The Insurance Council of New Zealand has embraced one of the country's official languages after launching its te reo Maori name - Te Kāhui Inihua o Aotearoa.

EQC offloads disaster claim management to Kiwi insurers
From the end of June, New Zealanders will have a single point of contact for natural disaster claims with the EQC handing over management of claims to eight local insurers.

News Bites
Latest Comments
  • Underwriting delays for nib special offer
    “I have a significant objection to a point in this communication, and I have raised it with nib directly. "In future, please...”
    22 hours ago by JPHale
  • Cryptocurrency; Advisers wary but must evolve
    “Financial services getting into crypto right now has the typical feeling of the mum and dad investor jumping in. FOMO is...”
    2 days ago by JPHale
  • FMA report slams insurers
    “There's a gap, alright. However, the mainstream media has missed what Matthew pointed out here, the real impact on the consumer...”
    2 days ago by JPHale
  • FMA report slams insurers
    “@Murray If 95% of legitimate well established and capable business did not meet expectations, might the age old saying "they...”
    2 days ago by LNF
  • FMA report slams insurers
    “Meanwhile, in the real world, advisers are still trying to secure PI cover by the end of the month so they can remain in...”
    2 days ago by Adviser1
Subscribe Now

Cover Notes - Specific news aimed at risk advisers

Previous News
Most Commented On
About Us  |  Advertise  |  Contact Us  |  Terms & Conditions  |  Privacy Policy  |  RSS Feeds  |  Letters  |  Archive  |  Toolbox  |  Disclaimer
Site by Web Developer and